Victoria police say they are investigating after receiving complaints about a Victoria church holding in-person Sunday services despite provincial orders that prohibit all religious gatherings until January
Oaklands Bible Chapel, at 2736 Fernwood Rd., has held in-person services with up to 50 people three times since provincial health officer Dr. Bonnie Henry issued an order suspending all events and gatherings until Jan. 8. In a Dec. 6 sermon recorded inside the church and posted to YouTube, the church’s pastor, Dan Anderson, said they would be holding in-person services on Dec. 6, 13 and 20.
Neighbour AJ Hildebrand has watched people stream into the church for the past three Sundays, and he’s noticed the church is advertising its in-person services online.
He said he was disappointed and “in shock” after discovering the church was hosting up to 50 people inside.
“An institution that is supposed to be about brotherly love and building the community is in fact jeopardizing it and stressing it,” he said.
On the second Sunday, he watched at least 25 people go into the building, many of whom were not wearing masks, he said. “Events like this can be super dangerous.”
By the third week, he decided to ask the church why they were violating the public health order. In a video he shared with the Times Colonist, he spoke to the pastor on Sunday, who told him there were 50 people inside the church.
Senior preacher Dan Anderson, who was not wearing a mask inside the church, deferred questions about the service to a sermon posted to YouTube.
During that Dec. 6 sermon, recorded inside the church and posted to YouTube, Anderson said the church followed the order for the first two Sundays after it went into effect on Nov. 19. But by the third Sunday, they decided to violate the order, he said.
He goes on to question the province’s response to the pandemic, saying guidelines are arbitrarily enforced and doctors in other countries have differing opinions on COVID-19 than B.C. public health officials. He claims without evidence that B.C.’s pandemic regulations are based on initial death toll predictions rather than current data.
“It didn’t pan out the way they said it was going to pan out,” he said, making the argument that the virus has not caused as much harm as predicted.
The pastor called the province’s reaction “a little bit disproportionate,” and invoked the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, saying Canadians are being denied their rights, and it’s the church’s responsibility to speak up when others are being targeted by government.
Oaklands Bible Chapel did not respond to a call and email requesting an interview.
Hildebrand said he reported the church to Victoria police after the first service, but he’s disappointed at the response. He spoke to an officer who said she talked to someone at the church, and they wouldn’t be holding another in-person service, Hildebrand said.
Hildebrand noticed the church stopped advertising its Sunday service after that, but then a notice went up again, and he informed VicPD.
Victoria police said they are aware of the complaints and are investigating. “We encourage everyone to follow the provincial health officer’s guidelines and the rules laid out in the COVID Related Measures Act regarding gathering and events,” said spokesman Cam McIntyre.
Hildebrand said he is worried a lack of enforcement against the church will embolden others to put people at risk.
“I fear that other people are just going to say: ‘Forget it.’ It’s going to be a cascade effect,” he said.
Provincial health officer Dr. Bonnie Henry said people who have taken all manner of COVID-19 safety precautions have been infected while attending religious services.
And while some religious leaders including Anderson have questioned why they can’t hold services while places like malls remain open, Henry said gathering indoors for a extended period is fundamentally different from conducting a transaction at a store.
“It’s not the same type of environment where we see transmission,” she said. “The virus doesn’t recognize that you’re in a church or in a home and during a mall, it recognizes opportunities for transmission.”
Several churches on the Lower Mainland have been fined for continuing to gather despite the ban. In a statement, Chilliwack RCMP said officers worked with regional health officers to try to gain voluntary compliance after congregants gathered on Dec. 6 and 13 at three separate churches.
On Thursday, police charged the churches with eight counts of failing to comply with the order and issued fines totalling $18,400.
The public health order does not prohibit people from visiting their place of worship for individual contemplation or prayer, and religious services can be held online.
