Evidence mounting of a school system in decline

 

Loss of provincial exams another step in weakening kids' education

 
 
 

This year is different for Grade 12 students heading for university. Except for English 12 or its equivalent, the Ministry of Education has abandoned provincial examinations in all senior academic courses.

Grade 12 exams are no longer offered in key courses such as mathematics, physics, chemistry, biology, history, English literature, French and Mandarin.

Students aiming for university entrance typically are required to achieve at a high level in three or more of these courses.

The decision to drop Grade 12 exams in academic courses follows a stream of similar actions taken over the past 10 years that have weakened standards in the public school system.

In 2002, the ministry began to retreat from routinely updating the provincial curriculum, the prime vehicle used to define what is taught in classrooms.

This was followed by termination of the school accreditation system, which served as a planning and accountability mechanism throughout the province. And in recent years, the B.C.

Teachers' Federation launched an aggressive campaign to undermine provincial tests in Grades 4 and 7.

These actions, combined with the never-ending conflict between the BCTF and successive provincial governments, are eroding the foundations of our K-12 school system and set the stage for a decline in the quality of public education.

A close review of recent international and national assessments suggests that the decline may have already started.

Reports from the latest Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development's Program for International Student Assessment show that while British Columbia 15yearolds perform at a high level, the province's global rankings have declined. The lower rankings are attributable to improvements in performance of other countries - and to actual drops in B.C.'s scores.

PISA reports show that between the years 2000 and 2009 the proportion of B.C. students attaining top international reading levels dropped to 40 per cent from 47 per cent. In mathematics, average B.C. scores also fell over the period 2003 and 2009.

In the 2010 Canadian mathematics assessment conducted by the Council of Ministers of Education, Grade 8 students scored below the Canadian average and were outperformed by Quebec, Ontario and Alberta.

The ministry's Foundation Skills Assessment for Grades 4 and 7 shows drops in the percentage of students meeting reading and numeracy standards, but the BCTF campaign against the tests obscures these results.

Educators in the topperforming school systems in the world are focused on the continuous improvement of teaching and student learning. This dominant focus is built on foundations that include a strong curriculum that is routinely modernized and a student assessment system that supports student growth and public accountability.

Not all high-performing school systems around the globe do things the same way. Successful systems reflect the unique culture and education history of each country.

Eliminating provincial Grade 12 exams is significant because this program has played a key role over the past century in developing tens of thousands of graduates who entered professions and who have played a leadership role in the social and economic development of British Columbia.

Although their design and content have changed over the years, the basic purpose of these exams has remained the same: to provide young men and women in every corner of the province - regardless of their social or economic circumstance - with the opportunity to work hard and attain levels of achievement that are readily recognized by top universities across North America.

A key feature of the Grade 12 exam program was that experienced teachers from across the province designed and marked the examinations.

Each year, hundreds of teachers reviewed student performance standards, identified trends and issues, and provided suggestions to their classroom colleagues on how to improve instruction.

This group of leading professionals played a central role in transmitting a culture of academic excellence to the next generation of teachers, probably the most important benefit of the program now being lost.

Experienced teachers and principals know that dropping these exams, and the absence of benchmarks they provide, will result in grade inflation and fragmented academic standards across the province.

From its modest beginnings in the late 19th century, the province's publicschool system has been built on solid standards to become one of the best in the world.

In a global society where education is a major determinant of the social and economic health of nations, eroding standards, weakening test scores and endless conflict are all indicators of a school system in decline.

Between 2000 and 2004 Jerry Mussio was Canada's representative in development of the OECD Program for International Student Assessment.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Location refreshed
 

Story Tools

 
 
Font:
 
Image:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

The Victoria Times Colonist Headline News

 
Sign up to receive daily headline news from The Times Colonist.
 
 
 

Latest updates

Jim Unger

Cartoonist Jim Unger, creator of Herman, dies at age 75 in Saanich

Unger, 75, had been feeling unwell for some time and died in his sleep at his Saanich home, his friend Adrian Raeside said Tuesday.

2 hours ago
Comments ()
 

Pickup truck stolen twice in four days

Now, not only are the thieves in possession of the man’s car, but also the keys to his house.

4 hours ago
Comments ()