Politicians shouldn’t be trusted on large projects

The Johnson Street bridge replacement is coming in over budget. The sewage treatment program is estimated to cost about 10 times as much, with many more unknowns potentially adding to the price, so any shortfalls will be higher and borne by local taxpayers. Additionally, the risks associated with building and maintaining a sewage pipeline are substantial.

We now hear that the neighbours of the Saanich composting facility are complaining about the noise and smell. When the sewage is pumped to Saanich to be processed, will it, too, cause similar complaints? If Saanich didn’t anticipate the problems caused by composting, what confidence should we have that the Capital Regional District will do any better with sewage?

The common thread in the bridge replacement and the sewage treatment program may be politicians who underestimate the scope and negative effects of such mega-projects. The bridge replacement needed to occur. On the other hand, most of the science says that additional sewage treatment isn’t necessary. Victoria has a unique geography that allows for marine-based disposal that is superior to what can be accomplished on land.

We should be asking municipal politicians whether they are willing to challenge federal and provincial politicians who have mandated this irresponsible project. Continuing on our current path will be devastating to our region.

Jeff St. Gelais

Victoria